Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies - Peacefield History (2025)

  • peacefieldhistory
  • 14 Comments
  • Inquiry Based Learning, Professional Development, Teaching Strategies
Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies - Peacefield History (1)

In recent years, I’ve noticed that Social Studies teachers are incorporating more writing into their classrooms. This makes my teacher heart happy, as I know that writing is absolutely crucial for students to understand and think critically about history. Obviously, whenteaching students to write, teachers develop strategies to make sure that student writing is sophisticated. One of the most common acronyms used among teachers is RACE.

I understand why RACE is popular. Many English teachers are utilizing RACE, so it’s easy for Social Studies teachers to carry the RACE acronym on over to Social Studies. However, RACE doesn’t fit SocialStudies curriculum very well at all. Therefore, I’ve adopted a different acronym for my classes – MEAL. I thought I would break this down with a comparison for each letter, so that you can see why MEAL makes a much better fit.

Restate

Here students are typically re-wording the question into a full sentence. I understand this approach, as it makes for an easy introduction for students.

Instead,use “Main Idea.”

With this, I have students give me thepoint they will argue with their paragraph. With a single paragraph response, I typically ask students a question I want them to answer. They know to start their paragraph with a generalresponse to that question that represented the main point they will argue, not just a rewording. For example:

Question – Why were colonists angry about taxation?

Main Idea –The colonistswere primarily angry about taxation because they didn’t have representation in Parliment.

Answer

I don’t need students to do this, as they already did so with their first sentence.

Cite

With this students typicallyprovide quotes from the text to support an answer they have given. I find this to be unnecessary. In upper-level History classes, students are typically discouraged from quoting. Therefore, I don’t want to start them out this way. Secondly, quoting in Social Studies doesn’t really add to the writing in Social Studies. Having students quote the definition for a particular act doesn’t tell me that they understand what that act really meant. (Students can still use quotes if they fit, however, it doesn’t pigeonhole them into doing so.)

Instead, use “Evidence.”

With evidence, I tell students to explaina historical event in their own words to support the main idea. I love this alternative because it can work for all levels of writing and naturally differentiates. For example:

Version 1 – They were angry when the Stamp Act was passed because they now had to pay taxes for legal documents. (Middle School)

Version 2 – Colonial leaders, like Ben Franklin, had drawn a line between virtual and actual representation. Although Parliment had argued that they had representation by being part of the British Empire, the colonists wanted actual leaders representing them in Parliment. Therefore, when the Stamp Act, an internal tax, was passed, some colonists were outraged. (Advanced High School)

See? In each of these versions, students are showing evidence of thought. This is a much better approach than having them simply quote the Stamp Act.

Explain

Explain is very similar to Analyze. However, I’d argue that analyze is more explicit in expectation. I tell students that I want to see how the evidence is connected to the main idea. Again, the analysis also allows for natural differentiation. For example:

“Analyze”

Acts like the Stamp Act showed the colonists that they were not being treated like British citizens. Those in Britain may be upset about taxation, however, at least they had representatives in the British government.

“Link”

Finally, my students end their paragraphs with a link back to the main idea. This reinforces the point they were making with their first sentence. For example:

Taxation alone didnot cause the colonists to protest. Instead, taxation without representation was what made them most likely to write petitions or boycott British goods.

MEAL for Paragraph Writing

If you put it all together, it reads like this:

Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies - Peacefield History (2)

I can use MEAL for individual paragraphs, and for the body paragraphs of an essay. I have students write this way in 7th grade and in AP. I’ve noticed much more detailed and thoughtful paragraphs since I’ve implemented MEAL.

Have you considered changing your writing acronym for extended response questions?

PrevPrevious10 Ways to use Pear Deck in your History Classroom

NextTeaching Evidence Based Argumentation through GamesNext

  1. I love this idea! When answering a question that forces students to use evidence from 3 or more sources, what would you suggest when using this format?

    Reply

    1. In that case, I suggest dividing the answer into multiple paragraphs, more like a DBQ essay. You can still use the same process with multiple body paragraphs.

      Reply

  2. I LOVE this idea! I am assigning my US History class (academic) an essay this week. I have found that I need to start from scratch as many students do not have experience with essay writing. I have 2 questions- do you have the MEAL image sold in TPT to be printed as a poster? And do you have a basic essay rubric you use-similar to your One Pager? -From an Econ teacher trying to teach US and World (totally out of my element!)

    Reply

  3. Trying this out today with my 7th graders. I did also notice Parliament misspelled above. 🙂

    Reply

    1. Glad to hear. Yep, I’m human. I make mistakes.

      Reply

  4. What about supporting details for your paragraph? There are supposed to be three supporting details for each the topic sentence.
    Should I place supporting details in the evidence or analysis?

    Reply

    1. ? I’m confused by your question. The E and A are the supporting details.

      Reply

      1. Thanks for responding to the question: an essay has three paragraphs (the body) of the essay. In the each paragraph in the body of the essay, I have to make a claim about my topic; this is followed by supporting sentence or details.

        But this style is an interesting style: main idea, evidence, analysis and link. The question I am asking is do I have one point for each paragraph in this style. You made me think about the question. This is not a jest.

        Second question: what are some questions to ask when making an analysis about the evidence?

        Reply

        1. Any question that requires the students to think about the evidence presented. It really depends on the topic!

          Reply

        2. Hi! I’ve been teaching this format for many years across many subject areas, and it lends itself quite nicely to multi-paragraph writing. If my students are writing a 5-paragraph essay, for example, each main idea or topic sentence should be pulled directly from their thesis statement. I also let kids know that they can have a really big meal with multiple pieces of evidence and analysis. The last thought should transition to the next paragraph.

          Finally, I teach my students that the analysis should illustrate HOW the evidence supports the main idea. As the reader, why is it important to understand this evidence to understand the larger main idea?

          Hope this help!

          Reply

  5. Great idea! I love this. I will be using this on my 7th grade Social Studies class. I want them to expand their ability to answer short answer questions.
    Thanks again.
    P.S. I can see this technique used in all subjects including explaining how students got an answer to a mathematical problem or for a Biology/Chemistry/Physics question.

    Reply

    1. Oh agreed!

      Reply

  6. I started using MEAL after I learned about this method in graduate school. It’s easily adapted to middle and high school, and I find that their writing is so much more precise. My sister is an elementary school teacher and still uses RACE. I’ve tried to convert her!

    Reply

    1. Oh believe me I have tried also. It takes some convincing!

      Reply

Leave a Reply

QUICK NAV

THE MONTHLY ROUNDUP

THE BLOG

THE SHOP

RECENT READS

Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies - Peacefield History (3)

© 2018 – 2024 PEACEFIELD HISTORY | PRIVACY POLICY

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.View Terms and Conditions

Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies - Peacefield History (2025)

FAQs

What does the MEAL in MEAL paragraph stand for? ›

The MEAL Plan (Main idea, Evidence, Analysis, and Link) is an effective strategy for constructing paragraphs. The Meal Plan is also an effective strategy for the writer to employ in the review and revision of each paragraph.

How to write a paragraph for social studies? ›

Paragraph – How to Write One
  1. Write a Topic Sentence. The topic sentence should introduce the main purpose of the paragraph. ...
  2. Introduce the evidence: (follow the steps below for each piece of evidence you use) ...
  3. Provide the Evidence. ...
  4. Provide reasoning/analysis for each piece of evidence: ...
  5. Provide a concluding sentence.

How to write a MEAL plan paragraph? ›

The MEAL paragraph starts with the central idea. Once you state it, you can provide evidence to support it. If the evidence needs to be analyzed for your reader's understanding, you do that next. Once the idea has been presented and backed with evidence, you provide a link to your larger argument.

What is the MEAL formula in writing? ›

One way to envision a body paragraph is as a “complete MEAL,” with the components being the paragraph's Main idea, Evidence, Analysis, and Link back to the larger claim. offer their main idea in the second, third, or last sentence; some don't have a single sentence that encapsulates the main idea.

What is a meal answers? ›

A meal is an occasion when people sit down and eat, usually at a regular time. She sat next to him throughout the meal. It's rare that I have an evening meal with my children. Synonyms: repast, board, spread [informal], snack More Synonyms of meal.

What does a stand for in meal? ›

Monitoring, evaluation, accountability, and learning (MEAL)

What are the 5 parts of social studies? ›

Teachers and scholars began to realize that these five subjects—history, geography, civics, economics, and sociology—were closely related.

What is paragraph writing with examples? ›

What is an example of a paragraph? A good example of a paragraph contains a topic sentence, details and a conclusion. 'There are many different kinds of animals that live in China. Tigers and leopards are animals that live in China's forests in the north.

What is a good sentence for social studies? ›

Examples from the Collins Corpus

I think I might do an essay on it for school - social studies. My father, a social studies teacher, remained smitten with her until the day he died. In 2002, a new middle school was built and the left-over wing incorporated into the high school, primarily as the social studies wing.

What is a link in a MEAL paragraph? ›

LINK! Now link the paragraph back to its original topic sentence. In the case of a MEAL paragraph, this refers to how the paragraph fits in with what the paper is trying to prove. Effective writers link the main idea of each paragraph back to the thesis/main argument. M – Main Idea: Topic Sentence.

What is MEAL plan in simple words? ›

Meal planning is making a plan of meals with adequate nutrition for every member of the family within the available resources. The term 'available resources' means whatever the family has in terms of time, energy and money. Meal planning is important for meeting the nutritional requirements of the family members.

What does a mean in MEAL paragraph? ›

argument. In keeping with our analogy of eating, we will use the acronym “MEAL” to indicate the primary parts of a paragraph: the Main idea; Evidence; Analysis; and Link back to the larger claim of the essay. The Main Idea: The main idea of a paragraph is its central thrust–that point which you want to prove at this.

What is the MEAL method? ›

The MEAL paragraph method is an approach to organizing paragraphs. It is especially helpful for longer academic writing projects (literature reviews, research statements, etc.) that require the synthesis of ideas across multiple paragraphs. The MEAL method uses four components: Main Idea, Evidence, Analysis, and Link.

What does meals stand for in writing? ›

MEAL stands for Main idea, Evidence, Analysis, and Lead out. You may have learned this paragraph structure early in your schooling as having a main or topic sentence, supporting sentences, and a concluding sentence.

What does meal mean in a text? ›

Definitions of meal. noun. any of the occasions for eating food that occur by custom or habit at more or less fixed times. occasion. the time of a particular event.

What does the term meal refer to? ›

meal | American Dictionary

an occasion when food is served or eaten, esp. breakfast, lunch, or dinner, or the food itself on such an occasion: I don't enjoy preparing three meals a day every day.

What is the meaning of the word meal? ›

1. : an act or the time of eating a portion of food to satisfy appetite. 2. : the portion of food eaten at a meal. meal.

What does the A stand for in the writing strategy meal? ›

A—Analysis: After giving the evidence, you'll want to explain, incorporate, and integrate that evidence by providing some analysis. Analysis is where you can compare, contrast, and provide explanations for the source material, why it is important, and how it relates to your main idea.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Trent Wehner

Last Updated:

Views: 6468

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Trent Wehner

Birthday: 1993-03-14

Address: 872 Kevin Squares, New Codyville, AK 01785-0416

Phone: +18698800304764

Job: Senior Farming Developer

Hobby: Paintball, Calligraphy, Hunting, Flying disc, Lapidary, Rafting, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Trent Wehner, I am a talented, brainy, zealous, light, funny, gleaming, attractive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.